When and Why to Abandon A Goal (Temporarily)

I recently taught one of my favorite workshops. A two-day dog training workshop where there were no dogs.

Yup, you read that correctly. Just people.

That surprises many trainers at first. After all, if we’re talking about dog training, shouldn’t there be dogs involved? Not necessarily.

Before we can effectively train dogs, we should strive to understand ourselves better.

We need to understand how behavior works (both ours and our dogs), how learning happens, how habits are formed, and perhaps most importantly, how our own assumptions and expectations influence the process.

So for two days, we strip training down to its principles and foundations.

We talk about behavior. Reinforcement. Motivation. Observation. Learning theory. We challenge our own beliefs and biases. We examine why we do what we do as trainers.

And we practice training each other. Unconventional? Maybe. Does it get results? Absolutely!

Throughout the workshop, I encourage participants to get curious and ask questions…lots of questions.

The moment we stop being curious and stop asking “why” is often the moment our progress stalls.

During a recent workshop, an interesting question came up: When should we step away?

It’s a simple question, but an important one.

If you’ve trained dogs for any length of time, you’ve probably experienced moments when training feels overwhelming, frustrating, or confusing.

You hit a plateau. Progress slows. The behavior you’ve been working on isn’t improving. You start questioning your training plan. Maybe you start questioning yourself.

What’s interesting is that most people tend to respond in one of two ways.

The first group tries to fix everything at once. They add more training sessions. More repetitions. More drills. More pressure. They start tweaking multiple variables simultaneously and often end up creating even more confusion for themselves and their dog.

The second group does the opposite. They avoid the challenge altogether. They stop working on the difficult skill and retreat to exercises that feel comfortable and successful.

Neither approach is particularly effective. One leads to overwhelm. The other leads to stagnation.

So what should we do instead?

Sometimes the answer is surprisingly simple: Step away.

Not from training. Not from your dog. Not from your goals.

Step away from the specific problem you’re trying to force into existence.

There’s an important difference. Our dogs are always learning, which means we’re always training. But that doesn’t mean every skill needs to be pushed forward at the same time.

Over the last 10+ years I’ve realized on more than one occasion some skills improve fastest when we stop obsessing over them.

Let me give you an example. My spaniel puppy, Archie, has been doing very well in her detection work.

Search motivation? Great! Odor commitment? Looking good! Problem-solving? Improving every week!

Her formal alert behavior, however, was another story.

I had a clear picture in my mind of what I wanted: an intense focused sit-stare at source.

The problem wasn’t Archie. The problem was my expectation.

At seven months old, she simply wasn’t ready for the level of precision and duration I was asking for.

The more I thought about it, the more I realized I was trying to build the roof before enough of the walls were in place.

So I changed my approach. Instead of continuing to push the final alert behavior in our detection training, I temporarily stepped away from that criterion.

We kept doing detection work. I reinforced changes of behavior. I reinforced a stand-stare at source. I reinforced moments of commitment under challenging conditions.

I reinforced all the pieces that are part of the final alert behavior. I just stopped expecting and pushing the sit-stare.

At the same time, we worked on many other skills outside of detection training that required focus, impulse control, body awareness, and duration. We practiced sitting and maintaining position in a variety of different contexts.

In other words, we continued building foundations.

Then, just the other week, something interesting happened. Without any prompting. Without any expectation. Without any pressure.

Archie offered a sit-and-stare alert. And I got it on video!

Exactly the behavior I had been trying to create months earlier. What changed?

The answer is that nothing changed overnight. The behavior wasn’t suddenly created. It had been developing the entire time. The pieces were being assembled slowly in the background.

And now the foundations have been built, the puzzle pieces finally could come together. She is readily offering her sit-stare a majority of the time in training (although I still reinforce her change of behavior/getting to source about half the time) which tells me our foundation is truly solid.

This is something I see repeatedly with dogs and trainers (and sometimes myself). We often become so focused on the end goal that we forget skills are built from components.

When progress stalls, it can be helpful to stop asking, “How do I get the finished behavior?”

Instead ask:

  • “What pieces am I missing?”
  • “What foundation needs more work?”
  • “What prerequisite skill hasn’t been developed yet?”

Those questions often reveal a much clearer path forward.

When training feels difficult, many of us naturally gravitate toward what’s comfortable. That’s human nature. We like certainty. We like competence. We like feeling successful.

But growth rarely happens inside our comfort zone.

The challenge is finding the balance between pushing forward and knowing when to give a skill room to develop.

So the next time you feel stuck, ask yourself:

  • “What habits are keeping me where I am?”
  • “What assumptions am I holding onto?”
  • “What is preventing me from trying a different approach?”
  • “What expectation might be getting in the way?”
  • “What small adjustment could create meaningful improvement over time?”

Notice that none of those questions begin with the dog. They begin with us!

Because progress often starts when we change our own behavior, our own expectations, or our own perspective and recognize our own biases.

Sometimes improvement requires more effort. Sometimes it requires a better plan. And sometimes it requires giving a skill enough space to breathe.

Step back. Focus on one component at a time. Build strong foundations. Then trust the process.

You may find that when you return to the original challenge, your dog has been learning the entire time.

 

Want email updates from Lauren?

Stay in the loop! Click the button below to sign up for the Momentum K9 email list.

As a subscriber to the Momentum K9 email list, you’ll receive 1–2 emails per month filled with helpful training tips, updates on upcoming classes and workshops, and exclusive event announcements.

You’ll also get early access to offerings—emails often go out before anything is posted on social media, so you’ll be the first to know!

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *